A Curious Sense of Justice

Posted: June 12, 2012 in Chinese Culture

Last week Global Times reported a story of one Shanghai woman’s very shitty day. While walking home with her son, she was all-of-sudden hit by a blob of falling poop. After complaining to the neighborhood committee, it was determined that the feces-flinger must have come from one of four apartments above where the woman was hit. She was awarded 600 yuan in damages (the article didn’t make clear by whom) but since the exact perpetrator couldn’t be nailed down, all four apartments were ordered to pay 150 yuan each.

The story shows one of the peculiarities of China’s legal rationale that’s presumably a remnant of socialism, or perhaps even Confucianism. Several years ago I read a very similar case (which I can’t find now) where a woman was hit by a falling plant vase and sustained nearly 100,000 yuan’s ($15,749) worth of injuries. But investigators could only narrow down the origin of the plant to 30 balconies, so, you guessed it, the residents were all ordered to share the burden at about 3,300 yuan ($520) a piece.

Over the years whenever I’ve gotten on legal topics with Chinese friends, I’ve mentioned this case. To my surprise, more often than not, they support the verdict. When I ask how they can justify punishing 29 completely innocent people, they’ve basically said “100,000 is so much money for that one innocent woman to pay, but 3,300 is relatively little for the others.” They admit that they’d be very upset if they were one of the 29 innocents, but in the end 3,300 yuan would merely inconvenience their life, whereas 100,000 yuan on top of debilitating injuries could very well ruin the victim’s life.

I can’t say I agree with this rationale at all, but it is intriguing. It’s especially interesting imagining what other circumstances are influenced by this collectivist mindset – where suffering is spread equitably and manageably at the expense of complete fairness.

Comments
  1. C. says:

    What I find fascinating about this is that, from a policy perspective, it provides a disincentive for people to behave responsibly. it winds up being a watered down tragedy of the commons.

    It does explain why China’s so dangerous compared to the West.

  2. Neville says:

    You may not be familiar with the legal concept of ‘joint and several liability’. This means (in western countries) that if many different people or companies contributed to a problem but only one can be found (or still exists, or has any money available to be taken) that sole defendant becomes liable for the entire amount awarded to a plaintiff, even if legally they were found by the same court at the same time to have been responsible for only a tiny percentage of the damage done. Suffering is thus concentrated inequitably and unmanageably at the expense of complete fairness…

  3. matt says:

    @Neville. Politely disagree. “Joint and several liability” switches the responsibility of sorting out and collecting damages from the injured party to someone who did something wrong (but maybe wasn’t 100% responsible). The unlucky defendant can sue the other wrongdoers to collect the other guys’ cut. The Shanghai situation looks more like an insurance scheme where everyone in compelled to pay their premium after something bad happens.

  4. Jeremy says:

    You could also say the others were being punished for their complicity. I remember in school when teachers couldn’t determine who threw the snotwad or whatever, and the other students refused to snitch, they would all be punished equally. This isn’t quite the same, but who is to say that one of the neighbors didn’t volunteer information about one of their fecal fetishist neighbors that could have resolved the issue?

  5. ask says:

    Excellent post. Keep writing such kind of info on your site.

    Im really impressed by it.
    Hello there, You have performed a fantastic job.
    I’ll certainly digg it and individually recommend to
    my friends. I’m sure they will be benefited from this site.

  6. Reuben says:

    %first_paragraphIt turns out that she was right, because optometrists give the same advice to their patients for healthy vision. Remember how your mother used to tell you not to sit too closely to the TV? On another note, it is easy to get headaches just by spending long hours in front of the computer screen, which can eventually lead to a series of eye problems.

    In the city of Wilkes Barre, Pennsylvania, people have the same need for optometrics. There is a number optometrist Wilkes Barre, including those in Engle Eyewear. A license to practice optometry is not only a state requirement but also proof and a form of warranty for patients that those who will care for their eyes are in fact competent to do so. In Engle eyewear, an optometrist Wilkes Barre is licensed to practice this profession.

    This is very important because so many vision and eye problems do not have recognizable symptoms at an early stage so those with problems do not have an inkling that they do and by the time you know about it might be too late already. Prevention is always better than finding a cure and having a regular eye check up is one way to prevent any unwanted eye illness later on. It is essential then to see if you have any vision problems early on for proper treatment and cure. This will avoid any damaging disease that may even result to loss of your vision.

    Therefore shed all your doubts and utilize this opportunity for your own benefit. Find more information about Lethbridge Lawyer here. All the necessary legal documentation procedures as well as proceedings are being handled in a hassle-free manner by such law firms. Resources:
    LE Lawyer is the author of this article on Lethbridge Law Firm.

    Thus, it is regardless to say tooth roots become weaker and you are subject to severe tooth related issues. Periodontitis
    It is another form of disease that is caused by plaque and bacteria are invited to destroy bones, tissues and capilaries and cause bleeding.

    This leads to a rising number of doctors of optometry to form group practice wherein every member focuses on a certain field while remaining still a full scope on their own practice. Other optometrists became professors or instructors while others perform researches and even consultations. While most doctors of optometry work as primarily a care optometrist, there are others that prefer to dedicate themselves in a particular field such as geriatrics, contact lenses, vision therapy or pediatrics.

    Today, every established dental hospital has a website with details about the locality and services they offer. So, with the help of internet, you can easily find the right dentist for you and your family. So, search for a professional like the Lethbridge dentist. Once you get to know the details about the hospital and the dentist, you can fix an appointment according to your convenience. So, when you are planning to visit a dentist, search for the best dentist in your city. This makes it possible to understand in what field the doctor is an expert and how and when can a person contact them.

    It is what he needs to read a contract so that he is not defrauded by anyone. It is what he uses to read so that as he gets a hold of a novel, he would be able to enter into that world painted by the writer. It is what one uses to look around so that he does not bump into things. It is what he needs to see the beauty and the ugly parts of the world and appreciate the balance of the same. They are the people educated and trained so that everybody would have perfect sight that is required do all those mentioned above, and more. The sense of sight is probably the most important or most valued senses in a mans body. That is why optometrists are essential in the world. But how will he be able to do all these if his vision is impaired?

    Therefore, if you need to find out more about a West Vancouver optometry clinic or other eye care treatments, there are a lot of websites that can help you acquire the information you need. com provide a lot of information on eye care options that you could perhaps want to ask your optometrist about.

    So, in order to avoid all such health problems, consult an expert like the Lethbridge dentist once in a while. Research has proved that toothache also leads to improper functioning of digestive system and headache which leads to sleeplessness. By following few simple tips, you are sure to have a good dental system.

    On another note, long hours spent in front of the computer can also lead to problems such as headaches, eventually paving the way for blurry vision. Do you remember when your mother advised you not to watch the TV screen too closely? Here are some useful tips to avoid blurry vision while you continue to do the things you like. It turns out that she was correct, as sitting too closely to the TV can lead to a whole lot of problems with vision.

    For admission in optometry school, you must pass the Optometry Admission Test. In order to be accepted in the program, at least three years of pre-optometric learning is required. Accredited optometry curriculum normally takes 4 years of study to finish. Majority of students joining an optometry course must have a bachelor’s degree.%

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s