On Beijing’s Anti-Japan Protests

Posted: September 15, 2012 in Politics
Tags: , , , , ,

Today saw huge demonstrations in front of Japan’s Embassy in Beijing to protest Japanese claims over the Diaoyu Islands. Two years ago when tensions last flared over this issue, I checked out the Japanese embassy in Beijing, where there were no more than about 50 people. This time, turnout was exponentially bigger and more serious.

I got to the embassy at about 1:00 this afternoon. The roads around it were all closed off to traffic with a few hundred riot police, regular police, public security volunteers and lord knows how many plain clothes officers. I estimate there were at least 2,000 people while I was there, although it’s unclear how many actively came to protest and how many were just curious onlookers.

In the middle of the street there was a partition with police directing people to parade around it in long circles. People had huge Chinese flags and banners saying things like “Fuck little Japan.” What I was most surprised by were the number of Chairman Mao posters floating around. I asked a few people about this and the consensus was “Mao would never let Japan get away with this.”

As the crowds paraded around, they sang patriotic songs, chanted “Little Japan, fuck your mother,” “Chairman Mao 10,000 years,” “China 10,000 years” and most significantly “Communist Party 10,000 years.” (“10,000 years” basically means “Long live…”)

This mass outpouring obviously had official sanction. The police’s presence was to direct the protests rather than try to hamper them in any way.

Later things started to get a bit more intense. While the crowds circled around they were allowed to stop briefly in front of the Japanese embassy itself. It was guarded by hundreds of riot police with helmets and shields. At first protestors threw water bottles and eggs at the embassy, which police made no attempt to stop. But gradually rocks and (I assume Japanese) cell phones started to be thrown. Many of them hit the Chinese police, who were covering themselves with shields.

One man brought a bucket full of rocks, which police came and confiscated somewhat violently. After a man chucked a rock, an officer wrestled him away and said, “Enough, they’re Chinese.” He then let him go. I caught up with the man and asked him what had happened. He said, “I just wanted to fuck Japan.”

Finally I went to interview a man on the side of the road holding a sign. As I was speaking with him a police officer grabbed my shoulder and turned me around. “What are you doing,” he asked forcefully in English.

I said I was just talking with people and taking pictures. He pulled me toward a small police post on the side of the road and demanded my passport. He looked at the visa page, handed it back and then seemed to get distracted with something else. I slowly but steadily walked away.

It was very strange. It seemed like coverage was being encouraged. I didn’t notice any of the other foreigners who were taking video/pictures being hassled. I’m not sure why I was singled out.

That was about the time I headed home.  If you didn’t understand what the people were chanting, the whole atmosphere of the protests seemed very festive. People chanted things, others laughed. Families with little kids were out, young people, old people. It kind of felt like a 4th of July parade…until things began to be thrown at the embassy.

This whole uproar is a godsend for the Communist Party. I never imagined I’d see people marching down the street with pictures of Mao Zedong chanting “Long live Mao, Long live the Communist Party.” It was a bit surreal. (Though several people were chastising the government for sitting by too idly)

It’s interesting to speculate on how much of this was deliberately egged on by the CCP. The whole thing erupted when the Japanese government bought some of the islands from a private owner. The move was intended to put the islands under national control so Japanese activists could be prevented from planting flags on the island and stirring up tensions. But it seems that was a huge miscalculation by Japan on the eve of China’s 18th Party Congress.

The Chinese media could have lauded the move as an attempt to ease tensions and work toward a peaceful solution, but it went hard in the opposite direction, portraying it as an illegitimate slap in China’s face. It’s no wonder so many are riled up.

It is important to note that when you see Mao posters being paraded, it’s probably a pretty poor representation of Chinese people. And it’s hard to say how many people present at the protest were active nationalists, how many came because they thought it’d be cool or interesting, and how many just happened to walk by and stuck around.

But there was a lot of intensity. Whenever someone started a chant, most joined in. This is clearly the most serious clash between China and Japan in a long time, and it could be far from over. A few days from now will be September 18th, the anniversary of Japan’s invasion of Manchuria. Unless there’s a police clampdown, the protests are likely to continue through at least that day.

With Xi Jinping back and all this intense anger directed toward Japan, I predict China’s leadership transfer can now go off without a hitch.

[Update: Below is a video I threw together of the protests with subtitles. See the rock chucker and hear a “Fuck the USA” chant]


“Angry eggs, free to take (everyone take 2)”

Notice the egg stains on the embassy

[If you want to use any of these pictures for anything, please either leave the watermark on or contact me to send you the original]

  1. […] were no more than about 50 people. This time, turnout was exponentially bigger and more serious. Continue related postSeriously questionableChina to strengthen M&A in oversea strategic resources and core […]

  2. […] 6:15 pm: Eric Fish of Sinostand has some high-definition photos from this afternoon’s protest. And apparently it was a nice day in Changsha as well: […]

  3. Stu says:

    ‘most significantly “Communist Party 10,000 years.” ‘
    Not sure it is most significant. I think it’s a defensive thing more than anything- a way of expressing that these are ‘loyal protests’ that pose no threat to China’s government.

  4. FOARP says:

    “10,000 years” basically means “Long live…”

    The Japanese pronunciation of those two characters is Banzai!

  5. Jacob says:

    I was there taking pictures (foreigner), and the same thing happened to me… passport demanded, didn’t have it with me, was ejected from the protest.

    • sinostand says:

      Interesting. I was wondering if the officer really intended to let me go or just got distracted and lost sight of me. Guess it’s ok as long as you have a passport.

  6. Jake says:

    Just get the Taiwanese Navy to reclaim Diaoyu on behalf of the Republic of China (and mine the waters around it to block japanese ships), and America can do nothing about it.

    • MB says:

      Taiwan is the country that insisted throughout on working out a peaceful solution with Japan (as opposed to the mainland’s belligerency), so not likely. And a lot of Taiwanese aren’t fond of the mainland either, so they won’t play along.

      And if China makes another demand of America like they did with the mural in Oregon, “can’t do anything about it” would not be something to rely on.

  7. […] searching for a good account of events, I found this Sinostand entry by Eric Fish, via Shanghaiist.com.  I posted in its entirety; I think it offers experience and […]

  8. […] a superb first-hand account of what’s going on outside the Japanese embassy in Beijing. In the middle of the street there […]

  9. […] China. There are lots pictures of the damage and a foreign reporter has posted an interesting account and video of the surprisingly large protests outside the Japanese Embassy in Beijing. It is hard […]

  10. Sucker tucker says:

    What a bunch of dicks

  11. Allroads says:

    Thanks for the post. Interesting to see what is happening in Beijing. Shanghai has been quiet (so far), particularly in comparison to 2005 … which was bananas for a couple of weekends.

    Where I think this gets tricky, if it is not reined in, is that there will be point that the gov’t cannot back off without losing face domestically. I’m not convinced the gov’t wants the domestic pressure to act, nor do they want to truly damage economic ties with Japan.


  12. You’d think the chant of “打倒汉奸”, or “down with Chinese traitors” starting around 1:41 in the video may have been of some concern to the authorities….i wonder whether it was allowed to continue throughout the day. I certainly didn’t hear it when i went down there on Sunday.

  13. […] gov’t buying islands (from a Japanese family) which China claims (for excellent coverage see Eric’s coverage at Sinostand). Friends in Nanjing reported seeing smaller crowds gathered and one emailed me to comment on what […]

  14. […] or “down with Chinese traitors” that is heard around 1:41 in this video from Saturday’s […]

  15. […] course not all Chinese are taking to the streets and looting stores. Website Sino Stand explains about a recent protest at the Japanese Embassy in Beijing: “It’s hard to say […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s