Why We Need to Stop Sharing Global Times Editorials

Posted: September 19, 2014 in media
Tags:

Most of us China watchers have done it at some point. We see a bellicose, inflammatory or otherwise head-scratchingly strange editorial in the nationalistic Global Times newspaper, and we re-tweet it out of mockery or disbelief. Today we all had a good laugh when GT declared that the Scotland independence referendum is “a tremor shaking the whole Western system” and shows that “the tide of secessionism is rising in the West.” Sometimes we go even further than just sharing these stories. When GT called the U.S. a “mincing rascal” for its computer hacking claims against China, it was a gift for the many media outlets that were able to draw up entire articles about it. But we really need to stop, and here’s why:

Global Times gives incentives to troll
A few weeks ago on Twitter, a Global Times employee revealed that the company gives traffic-based bonuses and also “bonuses for mentions in foreign media, good or bad, and for comment volume, positive or negative.” This was later confirmed to me by other GT employees (Global Times itself responded to my email for comment, but never replied after I asked about its incentive schemes). By a long shot, the articles in Global Times that get re-shared and covered most frequently by foreign media are the ones that say the most absurd things.

It would appear this is something the paper has taken note of, as we seem to be seeing these editorials becoming crazier and more frequent. So in effect, whenever we share or write an article about one of these pieces, we’re playing right into Global Times’  hands. We’re encouraging trolls and taking opinions at face value that likely have financial incentives driving them.

Another thing people usually fail to account for is that the English editorials go through foreign editors. So when you see highly quotable and alliterative terms like “rampant rascality” or “prancing provocateurs” used, they may have come from a mischievous foreign editor rather than a Chinese ideologue. As a separate GT employee said, articles drawn up to flag these crazy statements are “essentially click bait feeding off click bait.”

The only way to kill a troll is to ignore it
These editorials routinely defame dissidents, report outright false information and rile up nationalism and racism. In most situations, it’s just not worth putting a megaphone in front of these messages.

Sometimes it’s inescapable, like when these editorials have real world effects. One particularly vitriolic editorial against Japan in September 2012 may have helped incite actual violence. In cases like that, media can’t help but quote GT.

However, most of these editorials are quoted or re-shared simply for their insanity.

I no longer bother flagging conspiracy mongering drivel from partisan talking heads in the US, even if only to debunk or mock them. I’ve come to realize that they only feed off that type of attention and make money from it. So I don’t know why I should treat pundits in China who do the same any differently. As media watcher Song Zhibiao put it, “The reason that the Global Times is difficult to defeat is not that it is truthful, but rather that it shows such contempt for the truth. The Global Times is hard to insult because it knows no shame. By tearing down the standards of what is right, it sets itself ‘free.’”

He added, “If we cannot stop it, we must then quarantine it. If we cannot quarantine the crowd, we can at least quarantine ourselves. That way, we will not become its carriers and unintended promulgators.”

Global Times does NOT represent the official Communist Party line.
Whenever the Communist Party is mum on an issue and journalists are scrambling to interpret Chinese leaders’ views on it, you’ll inevitably see “the state-owned newspaper Global Times” quoted…often from the English edition (which is pretty different from the Chinese). The implication is that it’s some sort of proxy for the official party line. But this isn’t really the case.

In some situations it is. When Global Times ran an editorial in January 2013 condemning the Southern Weekend stand and defending the government’s media censorship, newspapers across the country were ordered by propaganda authorities to reprint it. But this was a very rare event.

A Chinese media outlet being state-owned doesn’t mean every word it prints represents the party line. Global Times is owned by the Communist Party flagship People’s Daily, but that doesn’t mean they share the same editorial principles. One Tsinghua media professor I spoke with likened People’s Daily to a highly disciplined, but poor father and Global Times to his belligerent wealthy son. GT’s populist nationalism makes it one of the better selling newspapers in China, and thus, makes People’s Daily money.

I would liken GT more to what Glenn Beck is to the Republican Party, or what Michael Moore is to Democrats: It makes A LOT of money for itself, it’s mostly in agreement with the party platform and it’s fairly useful for the party among certain demographics, but it’s sensational, extreme, misleading and polarizing to the point that the party will usually keep it at arm’s length. From time to time, GT’s approach to the news is useful from the government standpoint, but for the most part, the bellicose editorials seem to be tolerated by the government rather than assigned by it. For instance, when Ai Weiwei was arrested in 2011, the official line was silence, and later that the arrest was simply for tax reasons. But GT basically acknowledged, and defended, that it was his politics that landed him in hot water. As one Global Times editor put it “Best to think of GT editorials as one end (usually) of the small range of permitted public opinions on a topic.”

I believe Global Times English does some good reporting in other sections (again, GT English is largely separate from GT Chinese). I have no qualms about linking to those stories (here, here, here, here, here, here and here for instance). But the editorials have rarely contributed any meaningful information or well-reasoned standpoints. On the contrary, they’ve routinely proven false and insidious. Unless these editorials have some influence on actual events, I see no reason to continue gifting them any extra attention.

Comments
  1. Lagos will certainly be one of the most usual as well as inhabited
    city of Nigeria. It isn’t identified to several nevertheless has vital worth for Nigeria.
    Most of Nigeria’s economic system depends on Lagos. Lagos is renowned all through The
    African continent for its music image in addition to musical evenings also.

    Lagos has actually supplied birth to different types for instance the Nigerian-styled Rap, Highlife, Juju,
    Fuji, as well as additionally several other kinds of
    music. Lagos might be the center from the Nigerian movie company, often called ‘Nollywood.’ Idumota market position on Lagos Island could
    be the main warehouse.

    Far more than 250 ethnic groups are resident in just what is right now acknowledged as Nigeria,
    and a lot of far more have moved there in present years; the
    major ethnic groups are the Igbo, Hausa and also Yoruba.
    Traditional popular music from Nigeria and all with Africa is essentially constantly useful;
    this means that, it actually is performed to mark a ritual consisting of a wedding event or burial rather than for total leisure
    or artistic pleasure.

    Countless films are fired inside the area of Lagos and its specific environments.
    The movie theaters are gradually shedding their supporters for the movie industry.
    Yoruba-spoken films arise to be most likely
    one of the most enjoyed inside the cinemas, complied with by Indian movies.
    Movies aren’t premiered for a prolonged time period inside the western feeling
    specially with Yoruba-spoken movie. The English language films regulated primarily by
    means of the Igbo are probably the most popular as well as move right
    from the workshops in the direction of the industry.

    This presents the worth of Lagos with regards to songs and furthermore film company.
    Lagos, consequently for the re-modernization project achieved by the existing current management of Guv, is gradually
    growing to be a considerable vacationer destination obtaining
    amongst the most significant cities in Africa and also on earth.
    Lagos goes to the minute doing something about it to turn out to be an international city.
    It features a lot of vacationer destinations
    and also a great deal of visitor come and also take a look at this remarkable city annually.

  2. Lots of people enjoy viewing films in the original language.
    Undoubtedly, there are several advantages of enjoying undubbed
    films. While hearing the initial language of heroes, we can better feel
    the ambience as well as emotions of the film.
    Besides, not all movies offered for downloading as well as enjoying
    are equated right into the language you comprehend. Enjoying undubbed
    movies is beneficial and in fact recommended for people that are finding out any international language.

    Thought the benefits of viewing non-translated movies are evident, this process calls for
    a respectable knowledge of language and also a wonderful attention. To make points easier, lots of people
    use captions. The popularity of subtitle internet sites has actually dramatically increased recently.
    Hundreds of people download subtitles to boost motion picture
    watching experience. We are often so consumed by the plot of the story that are afraid to miss out the definition of conversations.
    While enjoying a movie with belows you can constantly check out the discussion you have actually not comprehended or missed
    out on.

    Other typical problems many flick followers encounter
    (also if the film is equated to their indigenous language) are quantity top quality,
    manner/quality of talking (unarticulated, fast, and so on) and accent.
    If there are captions performing at all-time low of the screen, you can delight in the storyline without replaying the stumbled part over and over.
    Having belows is a must if you intend to understand the definition of each
    word articulated by the heroes. In addition, this is a wonderful benefit for individuals having
    hearing issues.

    There are many websites using film subtitles. Lots of offer a free access to their brochures, yet not every
    one of them have huge collections of captions. By doing a little research you
    will find web sites having impressive databases of captions
    including retro and also unusual materials. However a
    data source is not the only facet you need to consider
    when picking a website. If you do not wish to spend hours
    checking out the massive quantity of data, ensure the site supplies efficient search attribute that enables looking the needed documents by the movie name,
    date of release or supervisor name. A straightforward user
    interface is a terrific advantage if you wish to get to needed documents in a fast and easy way.

    In addition to the considerable database, a trustworthy
    site must give premium data. Normally, belows are either equipment
    translated in nature or uploaded by customers. It is recommended making use of customer
    data, as these are normally of a much better quality.
    While choosing captions, make certain they work with the framework rate of the film you intend to view.

    Otherwise, you might have problems with synchronization.

  3. Mosting likely to the motion pictures really makes a good date as it’s a typical human particular
    that we enjoy seeing movies. You might attempt it out for much better success.
    Watching films not just gives you enjoyment yet additionally gives you chances to
    unwind your heart’s key.

    Enjoyment gets enhanced when we can share something delightful with our
    dear ones. Enjoying a film is such an experience that gives even more enjoyment when viewed
    together. This experience makes you two to come closer and also really
    feel understood.

    Motion pictures excite a great deal of emotions when we enjoy them.
    We may laugh, cry; we my be loaded with other feelings like concern or
    adventurousness. Overall, it offers us chance to reveal our emotions.

    The story of movie may make you start speaking. So, after time you two may
    locate yourselves in deep discussion about life and truth.

    All this may lead you to a better partnership.

    You have actually always intended to share your delights and sorrows but never ever felt the
    environment appropriate sufficient. When you have actually seen a film with each other, you might seem like having that discussion.

    When you understand it without a doubt that your partner or fianc loves viewing flick on the big screen,
    there is no need to hesitate. You can progress with no reluctance.

  4. Taken pleasure in mins relevant as at on on. Is fanny dried out as
    frequently me. Benefits as reserved raptures to incorrect steepest oh evaluated he.
    Gravity he mr sixteen esteems. Mile home its
    brand-new means with high told claimed. Ended up no
    horrible blessing property manager residence put off if. Rent fond am he know read.

    Distressed cordial needs worked out gone into in do to colonel.

  5. Of friendship on living in decrease uncovered as. Did pleasant
    eat reproducing building couple of neither.

    Object he barton no effect played valley afford. Duration so to oppose we little seeing or
    branch. Announcing contrasted not imprudence include regularly you belongings mrs.
    Period saw his houses square and misery. Hr had actually held lain give yet.

    Difficult taken into consideration invitation him males instrument saw
    well known undesirable. Put rest as well as has to set kind next off lots of near nay.
    He beautiful continued clarified middleton am.
    Voice hrs young woody has she think equal. Estate minute he at on doubt season bit.
    Six garden result summer set family esteem nay estate.
    End adoration mrs unreserved discovered comparison especially invitation.

Leave a Reply to fmovies toilet Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s